We set up 1500 point armies and rolled for the scenario and got Kill and Pillage. In this scenario, each player is awarded points for killing enemy units as well as holding objectives at the end of the game. Each objective was worth 150 points in this game.
Bill focused on my war trombones and wizards early in the game and managed to take many of them out of the game fairly early on. He also routed my trolls before they could get into combat.
Bill earned about 1000 more points than I did in the battle so we will call it a victory for the dwarves. I might have to adjust my army a little before our next battle.